From Service Outsourcing to Governance Outsourcing: Strategic Choices and Governance Consequences of Grassroots Communities under the “Creation Tournament” System
LU Qing-qing
Institute of Political Science and National Governance Studies, Central China Normal University, Wuhan, Hubei, 430079
Abstract:Alongside the modernization of grassroots governance, the tournament system has continuously expanded into the realm of social governance, giving rise to the “creation tournament”. The strong incentives and strict monitoring mechanisms inherent in the “creation tournament” have reshaped the landscape of grassroots governance, leading to challenges such as a sharp increase in governance tasks, heightened governance requirements, and growing governance pressures. These challenges have, in turn, forced a shift from grassroots social service outsourcing to social governance outsourcing. As a subtype of service outsourcing, governance outsourcing refers to the practice in which grassroots governments delegate certain foundational administrative tasks and social governance functions to third parties, leveraging their support to assist grassroots communities in achieving excellence and innovation goals. Within a relational structure where grassroots communities strengthen administrative control and institutional integration over outsourcing agencies, governance outsourcing manifests in operational mechanisms where third-party social organizations accomplish multiple grassroots governance tasks through “activity-based” approaches, address governance assessment requirements with “indicator-driven” methods, and meet the performance demands of grassroots communities through “brand-oriented” strategies. Far from enhancing governance performance, grassroots governance outsourcing has instead generated exorbitant governance costs, substituted governance actors, and deviated service targets, resulting in idle circulation of governance resources, detachment of grassroots organizations, and governance involution. In light of this, to better advance the modernization of grassroots governance, efforts should, on the one hand, focus on improving the grassroots governance ecosystem to prevent the overgeneralization of service outsourcing. On the other hand, it is essential to clarify the scope and boundaries of governance outsourcing and strengthen the primary responsibilities of grassroots communities.
卢青青. 从服务外包到治理外包:“创建锦标赛”下基层社区的策略选择与治理效果[J]. 《深圳大学学报》(人文社科版), 2026, 43(5): 98-109.
LU Qing-qing. From Service Outsourcing to Governance Outsourcing: Strategic Choices and Governance Consequences of Grassroots Communities under the “Creation Tournament” System. , 2026, 43(5): 98-109.